Slow and steady wins the race! Only $12,000 $5,221 more is needed to keep alive and vibrant for the next six months. A big THANK YOU to those who've contributed to our Fall Fundraiser so far. If everyone gave a few dollars (say, between five and fifty) we could get rid of this banner and go back to doing what we love most: helping people all over the Internet discover Krishna. If you give $25 or more, we'll email you a gift of the Bhagavad-gita audio book. How about that? Click here to donate.

help clear the doubt.

Recently i was reading Bhagvad Gita when i came across a sentence in 2.20 saying : " to kill someone's body without permission is punishable (kunachyahi sharirachi adhikaaravina hatya karne nindaniya ahe ) ".
I am confused with the word " permission ". Can someone please elaborate more on this and clear my confusion ..

Thanking you in advance.
hare krushna

iti artha

Are you talking about Hindi BGAII? I don't see anything similar to it in English BGAII 2.20p. but BG 2.19p. says: "Killing the body of anyone without authority is abominable and is punishable by the law of the state as well as by the law of the Lord."
"Without permission" and "without authority" are two different things. Does adhikara in Hindi really mean "permission"? In Sanskrit it primarily means "qualification". So authority/qualification here refers to a ksatriya defending dharma, like Arjuna.

Hari Hari
ys Jan

help clear doubt.

Thank you jan@VEDA for you help.
i am reading BG in marathi.And in marathi adhikaar means authority or right.
and earlier i understood it as one having authority to kill someone's body is not punishable and got confused with a person "buying" a chicken and having authority to kill and consume it.


By buying chicken you have mundane legal authority to kill it but you will still get karma because that's the result of killing against dharma. Otoh, ksatriya killing criminals gets no karma since he acts acc to his dharma.

Hari Hari
ys Jan